
American Idol @ MindSay 
It’s the end of the Season….
And lots of questions arise:
IS THIS the last show for Simon?
Will Kris somehow beat Adam?
Can Kara win the fans over?
Will Idol help out my review next year and get really embarrassing contestants?
Tonight Kris and Adam will perform 3 numbers…
* A song they previously did on the show
* A song picked for each of them by Simon Fuller, the show’s creator.
* A brand new song the winner will use as his first single. A song written by Kara.
So let’s get to it…
Round 1
Adam re-performed “Mad World” by Tears For Fears, which he had originally done back during the theme week ofThe Year they were Born.
IF you don’t remember hearing this song, that’s probably because this was the night American Idol went over their time and those that DVR’d the show missed out on Adam singing. So, it was a smart move by Adam to perform a song that many people would consider ‘new’.
Kris’ rehash is “Ain’t No Sunshine” which he originally did for the Top 9’s theme week of the iTunes top 10,000 or whatever it was called. He was solid then, and he was solid tonight.
I’m with Simon…Kris wins round 1…just barely.
Round 2
Simon Fuller is the creator of the Idol franchise and certainly one of the most influential people in Music history. I didn’t know what to expect from his choices, but felt for certain it would be some hit single by a previous Idol winner (or contestant).
Instead, Fuller picked 2 socially-conscious songs. No, not the Black Eyed Peas, “My Humps”. And not, “Cotton Eye Joe”.
Instead, Adam sang Sam Cooke’s classic, the civil-rights anthem, “A Change is Gonna Come”. It was a weird choice for Adam, though he did it as a straight ballad without a hint of protest.
Kris was given Marvin Gaye’s unforgettable, “What’s Going On?” While not bad, it just was flat.
Round 2…Adam
Round 3
Finally, it’s the song that will be the first single of the Winner’s post-Idol career.
As it has been since Season 1 the ‘Winner’s song’ takes the basic motif form of:
Whatever I believe and conceive, I will achieve
This is my dream, this is my one shot,you can’t take it away from me, as I will give it all I got.
Yada, Yada, Yada, I can do it, there’s nothing to it. Blah Blah.
This song was co-written by Kara, along with Cathy Dennis, who has been managed by Simon Fuller for decades. Dennis was the singer behind, "All Night Long (Touch Me)", and has since written Britney Spear’s “Toxic”, and Katy Perry’s “I Kissed A Girl”.
But, “No Boundaries” is a forgettable medley. I don’t even think Kara liked it herself but she was so hampered by the strict enforcement of the “I can try, I can do it” theme that she had no choice.
Let’s face it, except for Fantasia Barrino’s “I Believe” which was boosted by our perceived triumph of Fantasia’s dreams from her humble beginnings, the rest of the singles kinda stunk.
So the prediction is easy: Adam
Thank you for joining me this season. It was the hardest season yet to review as I’ve said.
Please feel free to send me comments, criticisms or your own analysis.
Have a great off Season. See you in 2010.
The final three show usually features each Idolator singing 3 songs:
1- The Judges Pick
2- Self Choice
3- A mentor’s pick
Tonight we only get 2 songs each.
C'est dommage
Paula’s picks for Danny.
She picks a song from the Terence Trent D’arby album that was called at the time “superior to Sgt Pepper’s”. Of course the only one that called it that was Terence Trent D’arby himself.
His followup album he said was superior to the Ten Commandments and the Sermon on the Mount combined.
D’arby’s “Dance Little Sister” was well performed by Danny who was then criticized by Kara and Simon for his dancing. Personally, I think Danny is a much better dancer than Moses or Jesus. But then again, YOU try to boogie in the desert wearing sandals!
Kara is given the ultimate humiliation. She is not given her ‘own’ song to pick for Kris. She has to share with Randy. Maybe they thought she was too new to the judging table to able to choose a song for a contestant on by herself and needed big Dawg Randy to help. The humiliation is worse when you consider that the producers thought PAULA had what it takes but Kara didn’t!
C’est dommage!
So Kara and Randy pick “Apologize” by One Republic.
I know this song was a big hit, in fact HUGE hit last year spending half the year in the top ten– but let’s face it. It sucks. Yeah, it’s one of those songs that gets stuck in your head forever. But so does every song played on Noggin’.
Kris performs the song as if he’s auditioning for the Wiggles. I think he’ll get the job.
Simon tells us how he contacted Bono and asked him if Adam could sing, “One” this week. Talk about Name-Dropping! Now, let’s just say “One” is one of the greatest songs of all time. Adam’s version is passable. Vocally it was good but it can’t match Bono’s or the interplay between Bono and the rest of U2.
Later, Simon confided that he had originally contacted the folks at Schoolhouse Rock! and asked them if Adam could sing “Lolly, Lolly, Lolly, Get Your Adverbs Here” but was turned down.
C’est dommage!
Danny is given the power to pick his own song. He decides on the Joe Cocker hit, “You are so Beautiful”. The Judges loved it. I thought it was just alright. Nothing memorable. Instead I would’ve picked a homage to Danny’s hometown, with a song written by Jerry Lee Lewis called, “What Made Milwaukee Famous (Has Made A Loser Out Of Me)”.
Kris picks Kanye West’s hit “Heartless”. It’s a very interesting version and certainly in my opinion is better than Kanye’s. Normally, I’d be afraid of insulting Kanye, who we all know is a self-titled, “genius”. But my opinion is shared by Randy who tells Kris that he too thinks his is better! Moments later, Kanye storms through the door of the American Idol studios and slaughters Randy Jackson! (actual depiction seen below)

Kara immediately looks at her decapitated associate and shouts out, “Ok, NOW can I pick a song for them by myself?!”
Adam’s pick is a little underwhelming… “Cryin’” by Aerosmith.
But if Adam isn’t in the finals this whole season was for naught, and we’d all be Cryin’.
So the Prediction:
The Wiggles are calling you Kris! Don’t keep them waiting!
BTW, I am actually thinking of taking the kids to see the American Idol tour this year. Between these 3, Allison, and one or 2 others I think this would be a decent show.
I've been forgetting to post these on Mindsay....SORRY!
It’s been a long time since I Rock n Rolled
Been a long time since I’ve been Simon Cowell’d
Adam Lambert rocked, He wouldn’t be topped
On Led Zeppelin’s Whole Lotta Love. Ooh yeah.
Simon was correct, Simon was correct
I even voted, voted, voted, voted, voted, voted for him.
We watched Allison doing her rock and roll thang.
It’s hard to believe she just turned seventeen
Her voice was so strong, singing Janis’ song
And I could tell she really belonged
That she should be, yeah should be
On that stage with Adam in the American Idol Fin-a-le
Singing out “I love rock and roll”
Putting another dollar in the iTunes baby
She rocked out Rock and Roll
Singing out Joplin’s Crybaby
Rock and Roll is here to stay it will never die,
Even if we only know a star, when Paula Abdul cries.
I don’t care what people say,
Kris Allen may deserve another day.
Rock and Roll week saw Kris sing, the Beatles’ Come Together
He was decent enough though last year, I thought Carly did it better.
I don’t care what people say,
Kris Allen may be there another day
.
Just take those old records off the shelf,
Danny Gokay performed some Aerosmith,
He sang it with a lot of blue eyed soul,
Randy loved that old time rock and roll
Though he wasn’t thrilled with Danny’s serenade
With Kris when they sang Styx’s Renegade
I thought their harmonies should be extolled,
I dug their old time rock and roll
I Wanna Rock and Roll All Nite
And Slow Ride Everyday…
Adam and Alle showed us everything they got
Their Foghat was something especially hot
They rocked out Slash, and he drove them crazy.
Let me hear some of that Rock n Roll music,
Seems like Kara DioGuardi is gonna lose it,
The Finalists - it will be hard to choose it,
No matter how well I review it,
Cause it’s gotta be Rock n Roll music,
But you can only vote for three.
You can only vote for three
“Hello, and Welcome to American Top 40. I’m Casey Kasem in Hollywood. Tonight, a special edition of AT40, It’s the ‘iTunes’ American iDol top 9. For the next hour we will count down the Top 9 downloaded hits of the nation as picked by our iDol Contestants.
Today’s Apple iTunes playlist is sponsored by the folks at iSuzu Motors, the makers of the i-Series heavy duty trucks.
iSuzu…the car company not controlled by the iDiots in Washington D.C.
We have as a special guest host this week, my good friend and future caretaker, the man with 1000 jobs…Ryan Seacrest.”
“It’s great to see you again, Casey.”
“Well who’s up first, Ryan?”
“As you know, Casey, we are inviting the iDolators to sing any song in the iTunes top 100 downloads of all time.”
“That sounds pretty broad. How will we know what was a top 100 download?”
“You’ll just have to take our word for it, Casey. Honestly, it’s a crap shoot. Again, thanks for letting me co-host. And now number 9, down from #5 last week is the son of a biochemist and a software engineer from North Carolina. Singing Usher’s “Caught Up” it’s Anoop Desai. Did you know that on American iDol we call him Anoop Dogg?”
“That’s interesting, Ryan. For 30 years I played a dog’s best friend as the voice of Scooby Doo’s buddy Shaggy.”
“Oh Really? I think I knew that. So can I introduce the next song, Casey?”
“My show. I’d like to do that myself”
“Would you let me do it for a Scooby-snack?”
“Did you say, a Scooby-snack? Like Zoinks! Like anything you say, old friend, old buddy, old pal.”
“Great, thanks Casey…At #8, dropping 2 places from #6, it’s the lovely Megan Joy Is Nuts--Mounds don’t. Megan has a beautiful and charming way of butchering a song and shrilling through a Chorus like a mouse sliding down the throat of a python. Megan said that while Bob Marley wrote “Turn Your Lights Down Low” for the great EXODUS album, Megan had decided to do Lauryn Hill’s version, which makes sense since we all will be running for the hills as soon as she starts singing. Unfortunately, she should have modeled her singing on Colbie Caillet’s performance on her Coco debut CD.”
“Like Thanks, Ryan. Like Wow. Awesome Scooby Snacks. Now, we are approaching #6. Danny Gokay falls from the #2 position last week. He’s still going strong with the 2006 hit single by Crossover-Country superstars Rascall Flatts, “What Hurts the Most”. I’d have to say what hurts the most is still the painful trill in my ears from Megan’s vocal torturing.
But, now we turn to this artist, who once won a Telemundo competition for 50,000 dineros. Currently, she’s only 16 years old. Wow, I have hair plugs older than that, Ryan! Here to belt out Gwen Stefani’s breakthrough song, it’s Allissssson Iraheta.”
“No Doubt, Casey.”
“Yep, there’s no doubt that Allison is a force to be reckoned with this season.”
“No. No Doubt”
“That’s right Ryan. Allison is awesome with her red hair. No Doubt about it.”
“No, it’s not Gwen…oh, forget it. Casey, the only thing going wrong with Allison is that her guitar playing is worse than Stevie Wonder playing Guitar Hero. Imagine that Casey!”
“Ryan, that’s just silly typical morning disc jockey banter. I refuse to stoop that low. But, now it’s time for our ‘Long Distance Dedication’ segment. This Long Distance Dedication is from Dave in Albany, New York. It’s to Scott MacIntyre in Hollywood.
Dave writes, “Dear Casey. I grew up in western Long Island, but when I was a baby I went nearly blind. My eye sight has kept me from doing several things in my life, but it hasn’t stopped me from keeping a blind eye to the problems of the regular people, like the obese, like people who need lots of haircuts, people who download from iTunes – today’s sponsor! – Or anyone who watches TV, eats, drinks, reads, fishes, camps, buy something, goes anywhere, or wears anything. I plan on approving a budget that will destroy the lives of most New Yorkers. So, please Casey I want to request for my sight-challenged compatriot Scott to play, “Just the Weight You Are” by Billy Joel. It will remind us all that the fatter you are, the more revenues we will try to extract from your wallets. Thanks Casey. Signed, New York Governor David “No Budging on the Budget” Paterson.”
“Well, Dave, here’s your long distance request for Scott.
“Now, on with the countdown! In the number 4 spot, up 6 spots from last week is Kalamazoo’s own Matt Giuard. Matt is a dueling pianist. What does that mean Ryan?”
“Casey, I have no freakin clue. I say it every week but it’s just stuff I read off a cue card. Tonight Matt pitches in on a song by the Fray called “You Found Me”. While it will be an ok rendition, Matt could’ve picked the Fray’s other big songs like “How to Save a Life” or “Over my head”. Right, Casey?”
“Ryan, the last new artist I remember hearing was back in 1988 when a group of brash youngsters with a great look released an album called ALL OR NOTHING, eventually retitled GIRL YOU KNOW ITS TRUE. Yes, Ryan, I’m talking about the one and only Milli Vanilli.
For our # 3 song, Little Lil Rounds Surrenders to Celine Dion and our iTunes sponsor with “iSurrender”. It’s available tonight on your iPhone, iTouch, iPod, or iDon’tgivearatsass.”
“And now we are up to our ‘Where are they now?’ segment.
This band hit it big back in 1976 with the R&B tinged duet with Richard Pryor, “Play that Funky Music, Cracker”. After trying to keep the momentum going with, 1977’s top ten single “Play that SoulGold Music, Honky” with Red Foxx, and the 1980 New Wave hit featuring Bill Cosby, “Play that Jello Music, iSpy”, the band broke up. They tried to reform in 2001 with “Buy our Discounted Music, Wal-Mart” but the magic was gone. So, tonight on American top 40, here’s the music of Wild Cherry as done by Adam Lambert.
“Casey, I really enjoyed Adam’s version. It wasn’t the same old, same old. Just different and fun.”
I agree, Ryan. But we’ve climbed to the top of the mountain. The new #1 is the country this week is Kris Allen with another solid performance of Bill Wither’s “Ain’t No Sunshine”.
American Top 40 is distributed by Premiere Radio Networks as well as Gmail, Yahoo, Optonline, Verizon, Hotmail, AOL, and MSN. I’d like to thank Ryan Seacrest for sharing the stage with me and our judges, Kara, Paula, Randy and Simon. And Remember, ‘Keep your feet on the ground, and keep reaching for the stars.’ I’m Casey Kasem.”
Showing 1 - 5. [ Next ]
carrie underwood
