Tattooedjen  reports of a strange and personal new health requirement in Japan. In a country we would hardly deem at risk for obesity due to their healthy diets, the government is working on a required method that will reduce obesity, or "metabo" by 25% in 7 years.

Citizens of Japan are being called upon to have their waistlines measured. The new prescribed limit for a male's waistline is 33.5 inches. For women, it is 35.4. The targeted group for measuring are those of ages 40 to 74, which is a little less than half of their population. If after 3 months they are unable to lose the inches, they will be given dietary guidance. For those who cannot lose the inches in 6 months, they will be given "further re-education."

In America, the average waistline for men is 39 inches, and for women it is 36.5. How would you feel if such a law were enforced in your country? Is the government overstepping its boundaries? Do you think this will have a positive or negative effect on body image in the Asian country?
 
   

 


Comment Page: 1 2 3 4 5   [Next]
 
missmandible on
Re: Put Down the Rice or We'll Call The Cops
I have 5 words for the Japanese government:

 

Mind your own fucking business.

 

I would appreciate having people in my life who cared enough about me to help me along, and give me encouragement and support. People are left to their own devices, thrown to the wolves, kicked aside nowadays, even by their own families. Asking for help means youre weak and worthless, you should be able to do everything and anything on your own. And thats bullshit. We all need help and love when we ask for it, when we try to help ourselves and fail. But if these same people made it mandatory for me to lose weight to be part of their family or circle of friends, i'd tell them to go fuck themselves.

 

HOWEVER....maybe they should do that. Is overeating and not exercising and not taking care of your health any less dangerous than what a drug addict does? How many people have we cut from our lives because they cant get their cocaine usage under control, their drinking under control? We cut people out of our lives who refuse to get help for their problems, but is slowly killing yourself by eating unhealthy any different? (I think its different, but its just an interesting way of looking at things.)

 

I just wonder what the real motivation is behind these tactics of the Japanese government.

 

What could be a better solution for us to help ourselves and our loved ones without shunning people or resorting to these extreme measures? It hurts people to see us killing ourselves by way of food and/or sugar consumption, just like it hurts the families of alcoholics and drug addicts.

 

Maybe if healthy food and drinks tasted better, i'd be much less of a fatass. LOL

beccsaloser on
Re: Put Down the Rice or We'll Call The Cops
i haven't even read your whole comment.

but i agree with the first two sentences.

 

yahh trick yahh!

Unitedybevol on
Re: Put Down the Rice or We'll Call The Cops
I don't like it either... but think about it this way: Some people are just too lazy, this is their motivation. Some are shy, this is their chance to blend in (everyone's doing it), some are stubborn... there's nothing you can do.

I don't think it should be a Governed thing. It's our bodies and our own free will. But then again, we don't always know our bodies best. And we definitely don't always do things for the better.
SaikotikGunman on
Re: Put Down the Rice or We'll Call The Cops
Well, if they ever mandated those specific measurements here, there'd be a problem.  On average, European and African ethnic groups have a larger frame than Asians.  The lowest healthy waistline I think I'd be able to reach would be 36 or so.

Of course the government is overstepping it's boundaries.  Find one that's not!
36exposed on
Re: Put Down the Rice or We'll Call The Cops
The Japenese government should make all of their people drink King Cobra so that they'll get the shits.
whispertales on
Re: Put Down the Rice or We'll Call The Cops
From the NYT Article on 6/13 (emphasis mine):

Those exceeding government limits — 33.5 inches for men and 35.4 inches for women, which are identical to thresholds established in 2005 for Japan by the International Diabetes Federation as an easy guideline for identifying health risks — and having a weight-related ailment will be given dieting guidance if after three months they do not lose weight. If necessary, those people will be steered toward further re-education after six more months.

 

Important to recognize that it's not just a waist measurement, but a waist measurement in addition to a known weight-related ailment, that is the trigger for dietary guidance.  There is no penalty associated with being over the prescribed limit.

 

I give kudos to the Japanese Ministry of Health for taking the health of their nation seriously! 

 

missmandible on
Re: Put Down the Rice or We'll Call The Cops
I give kudos to the Japanese Ministry of Health for taking the health of their nation seriously!

 

See, i'm kind of on board with you there. I do think it would be awesome if TPTB took an active interest in their citizens' health. Not by mandating things, but by offering more services, offering solutions. Services and solutions for everyone, though. Not just those who can afford it. I dont mean allowing every Tom, Dick, and Harriet to get gastric bypass surgery, but offer them clinics and classes and programs. I would take them up on those offers in a heartbeat. Its hard for me to do it alone, especially when youre married to someone who can eat whatever he wants, exercise however little he wants, and not only NOT gain weight..but somehow lose it! Its a struggle for me, and not him, so he's not very sympathetic or understanding. Same with all of  my friends. I'd love it if our nation actually cared about our HEALTH...not our LOOKS.

semiomniscient on
Re: Put Down the Rice or We'll Call The Cops
As long as it is not mandatory, I don't see the problem with government providing it.  I don't like the idea of mandatory health care in the case of competent adults.  (Infants, mentally disabled, etc. madatory health care is probably a good thing.)  It's nice that the Japanese government is taking health seriously (and even nicer to know that added information you provided about having weight-related ailments)... but I don't think it's a government's job to police eating and exercise habits of its citizens... barring dire circumstances like severe famine.  Just like I don't want the government in people's bedroom, stay out of the kitchen too.  :-)
DarkSalem on
Re: Put Down the Rice or We'll Call The Cops
I think it should be up to people what they do if it doesn't effect anyone else.. and also, who's to say what is a healthy waistline? People are of different shapes and sizes... but besides that, I think the idea is good. It would be nice to have "dietary help" if wanted. I would embrace it, but I don't think it's something that should be forced unless the population is in a critical situation somehow...

Comment Page: 1 2 3 4 5   [Next]
Login to replyToggle picture size
 

Latest Comment
Re: - That was such an amazing show -- what a cast! And could anyone feather hair as well as Gary Sandy? ROFL

Read...


 
© 2005-2007 MindSay Interactive LLC
| Terms of Service
| Privacy Policy
My Account
Inbox
Account Settings
Lost Password?
Logout
Blog
Update Blog
Edit Old Entries
Pick a Theme
Customize Design
Modify Plugins
Community
Your Profile
Wiki Pages
MindSay Tags
Video & Photos
Geographic Directory
Inside MindSay
About MindSay
MindSay and RSS
Report Spam
Contact Us
Help