Leroy Schad, 72, from central Kansas, received a punishment for the public – rather than quietly be convicted of a sex offense against a minor, the judge overseeing the case ordered Schad “…to five years of probation and house arrest…” in addition to “…posted signs around his house and a decal on his car proclaiming that he is a sex offender”.  

Schad, unhappy with the enforced posting rule stated, “"I know that I deserve something for that, but I don't think I deserve what I got”.

Perhaps if more criminals were forced to wear a symbol of their sin public shame itself could be a deterrent to committing future crimes.

Do you think that the Judge’s ruling is unfair or that a badge of shame should be applied to other type of criminals publicly announcing their crime?

This report was contributed by Danielle Morrison

[link]
 
   

 


Comment Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6   [Next]
 
supertree on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
I think it's fair, and something that should be done more.  Maybe the possibilty of being judged by those around you and having to physically and emotionally walk around with what you've done will make a person think twice.  Though it would be hard to figure out what to do if they are a "changed person" or if they changed at all.
katmanndoo on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
I love the "badge of shame" idea. And I agree that there might be fewer criminals if everyone had to wear something saying what they had done. I recently got an email with pictures of a mother sitting on the sidewalk while her son stood holding a sign that said "Hi. I'm 13 years old. I like to steal. I want to go to prison like my daddy." That would be the ultimate in public humiliation for a teenager. I can't think of a more perfect "sentence" for a crime.
Silencingshorty on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
Ba ha ha ha ha, that's *awesome*
decisiontime on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
Good idea!  This is why God never shows his face, by the way.  He's ashamed that he impregnated the 13 year old Virgin Mary.

bonniegirl on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
On your high horse again, I see!  He did not have to do any of the sordid deeds you are always thinking about to do that, you know.  All he had to do, as with the creation of every living thing, was just to say the word.  I know he formed Adam with his own hands, but that is because he loved crazy people like you, and it is about time you should realise that. He 'overshadowed' her (could do nothing else anyway, as a spirit has no flesh and blood) to robe himself in the only flesh he ever knew, to die for sinners such as you and me. 

 

You ought to be ashamed of carrying this stupid statement, as it only shows you up for the ignorant person you are. 

 

And yes, he showed his face, in the face of Jesus who had no sin, and in the face of every Christian who allows him into their hearts, and personifies him.

 

So why not at least stay on track when answering a question, instead of going off on a tangent in this silly manner?

decisiontime on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
I know you're ignorant, but what am I?

daenarys on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
My personal opinion on this is that I wholeheartedly agree with the concept. That being said, in order to enforce this sort of thing, you would pretty much have to legislate that convicted sex offenders no longer have any rights as an American citizen.  There are too many bleeding hearts out there though who would work hard to prevent such a measure from taking place... after all, "Sex offenders are people too"...
SaikotikGunman on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
Torn a little.  I'll think on it some more.
brandre on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
I am in favor of it but like you I have reservations. There would have to be some safeguards.
SaikotikGunman on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
I worry about any program that infringes this much on a citizen's rights, even if that citizen is a criminal.
semiomniscient on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
What right specifically does it infringe upon?  Isn't a prison sentence an infringement upon certain rights someone has?
SaikotikGunman on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
Being in prison is equivalent to enrollment in a total institution, such as joining the Armed Forces.  Total institutions retain the power to restrict rights.

By not being in prison, he is no longer within the bounds of that institution and it becomes illegal to infringe upon his rights.
semiomniscient on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
So how is "house arrest" legit?
SaikotikGunman on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
It's a legitimate punishment, but you're still existing on mostly your own terms.  It is not a total institution scenario.
semiomniscient on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
And a "Scarlet Letter" doesn't keep you from existing on similar "own terms" does it?
SaikotikGunman on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
No, but it makes you a target and sitting duck, as well as your relatives and friends who may be seen with you.
semiomniscient on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
That's a good point.  But isn't the purpose of the "Scarlet Letter"  public humiliation and ridicule?  Isn't one deserving of a prison sentence deserving of public humiliation?
SaikotikGunman on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
Prison sentence, yes, public humiliation, no.

It's a matter of fallout and cruel and unusual punishment.
semiomniscient on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
I don't think it's cruel and unusual punishment.  I don't think chain-gangs are cruel and unusual.  I don't think public flogging is cruel and unusual (of course there are limits.)  I don't like this "time-out" mindset people in our nation have in regards to breaking the law.
SaikotikGunman on
Re: A Modern Scarlett Letter
I think prisons are too user-friendly, yes, and outside the bounds of legality, I am a strong proponent of public flogging.

The difference there being that those the subject interacts with are not threatened.

Comment Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6   [Next]
Login to replyToggle picture size
 

Latest Comment
Re: Some ecards I've considered sending... but never will. - Hahaha, those are awesome! I believe the "It...

Read...


 
© 2005-2007 MindSay Interactive LLC
| Terms of Service
| Privacy Policy
My Account
Inbox
Account Settings
Lost Password?
Logout
Blog
Update Blog
Edit Old Entries
Pick a Theme
Customize Design
Modify Plugins
Community
Your Profile
Wiki Pages
MindSay Tags
Video & Photos
Geographic Directory
Inside MindSay
About MindSay
MindSay and RSS
Report Spam
Contact Us
Help