http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/101972.php

 

Are you saying that being a "normal" weight doesn't necessarily mean you're healthy?  DUH!

 

Some of you know that I have got a bone to pick with medicine these days.  I'm not saying I'm in great shape because that is far from the truth, however my cholesterol is normal, I have normal blood pressure and normal blood sugar.  I took my blood pressure today and it was 110 / 80.  My doctor always tells me I should bottle up my blood pressure and sell it. 

 

My experiences with some doctors have been horrendous.  When I was pregnant, my OBGYN was such a jerk that he kept insisting that I was going to develop some sort of complications with my pregnacy because of my weight.  My pregnancy was perfect.  I didn't even develop edema until two days before I went into labor. Meanwhile, the poor girl in the next bed in the recovery room was suffering from pre-eclampsia and her baby was premature.  This girl was within a "normal" weight range. 

 

One time, when I went to the doctor complaining of fatigue, irritability and general forgetfulness in addition to muscle twitches, I was told to lose weight and change my diet.  He didn't run any blood tests. Per his suggestion, I went to a doctor who specialized in weight management.  He took a blood test and TADAAAA! I had high blood calcium which explained every single one of my symptoms.  Incidently, high blood calcium has NOTHING to do with weight! I've heard stories almost identical to mine from many of my overweight friends. 

 

Anyway, this mini rant was inspired by an article stating there is a new, very absurd term out called "normal weight obesity".  Basically this is a round about way of saying being within the normal weight range doesn't mean you're free from obesity related conditions.  I'm not saying that being fat is healthy, I'm saying that being fat doesn't necessarily mean you have one foot in the grave and being within a normal weight range doesn't mean you're better off than the fat guy next to you. Maybe now all of us can walk into a doctor's office, be properly examined and have our symptoms taken more seriously.

 

http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/101972.php

 

http://www.mayoclinic.org/news2008-rst/4738.html?rss-feedid=1

 
   

 


Comment Page: 1 2   [Next]
 
callie69 on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
your rants are always sooo good! i agree with you!

myclette on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
Thanks Callie.   I am not going to say being overweight is healthy, I'm just saying it doesn't necessarily mean you're a hotdog away from a heart attack.

 

 

I miss your posts by the way.

callie69 on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
that is so sweet of you (hugs), i'll have ot finish my last one for you

myclette on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
Yayyy!
resable on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
Nor does it mean you are lazy, unmotivated, slovenly, smell bad, unsexy, stupid, piggish, always jolly or want to wear shapless sacks as clothes. OMG, have you ever touched upon one of MY hot button issues!!!! I actually had one doctor tell me ( before he even bothered to do an exam), " You know, you are overweight." I replied, ( with a pseudo shocked expression on my face) , " I AM? Oh my GOD!"

And I am using this reply area to AGAIN shout a constant refrain; BEING OVERWEIGHT IS NOT A CHARACTER FLAW!
myclette on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
Amen!  What's up with these doctors chalking everything up to people's weight when they walk into the office??? Ugh!

 

Being overweight isn't a character flaw, but being a judgmental jackass is! *high fives you*

resable on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
They're legally and ethically bound to tell you what you need to know, but for God's sake, keep the judgemental shit to yourself.
I don't go for doctor's for lectures.
myclette on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
True, but could they tell me how fat I am while running tests?  LOL!
resable on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
I dont even have a problem with them sitting down and discussing it, as long as it is done with respect and facts and for my overall benefit MINUS the disgusted looks, MINUS the raised eyebrows or clicking tongues when looking at the numbers on the scale, MINUS the multitudes of suble ( or not so suble) innuendos that you are subhuman.
SaikotikGunman on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
A lot depends on why it is you're overweight, too.
myclette on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
Yes it does.

SaikotikGunman on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
If you go by the BMI thing, I'm close to being in the obese category, if I'm not in it.  But I was out throwing hundred pound bags of feed around like cotton candy, too.

The whole thing is messed up.  Any system that categorizes people is doomed to fail.
velvetdreams on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
Preach it, Sista!  My numbers are all great, too ... except the weight one!  My last bp was 118/72!  and my resting heart rate is 68!  lol The only disadvantage at this point is that my knees are starting to feel it, with all the up's & down's of working with toddlers!  Other than that, I'm one of the healthiest people I know! 
myclette on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
My knees are terrible, but my 115 pound sister has problems with her knees, too. So does my mother.  It's hereditary, but I know my weight makes it worse.
velvetdreams on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
It is rather amazing the information that's encoded in those genes, hmmm? 
shiny on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
Absolutely! People are often shocked when they see that someone my size can often outwalk them, uses the stairs instead of the elevator when possible, and doesn't always think about food. Granted I acknowledge that I do need to lose weight (and am working on it), but I know many of folks not overweight who lead a far less healthy lifestyle than I. The whole stereotype makes me shudder.

At least it's not as bad here as it is in that town in England where they're fining parents because their kids are overweight. Sheesh...

-- S

ubu13 on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
I certainly give a hoot too!  I'm one who has always always had to fight my weight.  And yes, I've had doctors on my case even back when I wasn't that heavy.  One creep said I would never have boyfriends if I was fat.  Ha!  Ask my friend here about that ;~)  Anyway, I'm old and falling apart now and still fighting the weight.  I did finally get high blood pressure (mostly from the stress of a doctor telling me I had ovarian cancer and it turned out to be a dermoid cyst on my ovary, for which everything came out and then my estrogen levels were zilch and I began to develop high blood pressure and high cholesterol after 58).  I have lots and lots of bones to pick with allopathic physicians.  They are mostly just guessing things except when they put you through horrific tests ;~)

And oh yes, my latest physician now calls me a little dumpling.  I like that...great post, Myclette

myclette on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
Good grief! Being misdiagnosed with cancer would raise my blood pressure, too!

 

What kind of doctor tells you you won't have boyfriends??? Damn!

ubu13 on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
Nope, I am not kidding.  I lived for 5 weeks with that misdiagnosis until I had surgery.  The first thing I heard when I woke up is "you don't have cancer". 

 

During that 5 weeks was when my blood pressure went up for the first time and I had to tell the doctor about it.  Also, when my father was dying of a stroke, he told them in the hospital that he had had one (as he had several before) and they said "no, you are having a kidney infection".  The next morning he was dead.  I was in California and didn't have a chance to get back to see him in Philadelphia because of that.   Also, my mother had Lupus.  It was not diagnosed in Memphis, TN.  In fact, they had her in a mental hospital, writing letters to her dead husband, because they said that was what was the matter with her.  I can go on and on, Myclette.  I really really dislike going to the regular doctor's.  I try to see alternative ones whenever I can afford them, but they are not covered by my insurance. 

 

The doctor who told me I wouldn't have boyfriends was in 1966 in Alaska.  I had gone from around 115 to around 125 or 130 or so.  Can you imagine?  It didn't hurt my libido, to say the least ;~) (nor I don't think, my ability to attract me)

ubu13 on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
whoops.  That last word was supposed to be "men", not "me".  Had my glass of vino for my cholesterol for the night, and look what happens ;~)
myclette on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
This sounds like an absolute nightmare!

 

That doctor in Alaska was an ass!  I never had a problem getting boyfriends. As a matter of fact, I seemed to get more boyfriends in college AFTER I had gained weight. Go figure.

ubu13 on
Re: No! You're KIDDING!
I agree.  But of course, in Alaska, I was only 21 and it was quite a while ago.  I've been married for 39 years, so it hasn't hurt me too much...zoftig is the word people use...ha ha. 

 

But you can see why I would distrust traditional western doctors.  And to make matters worse, I grew up with an osteopath in Philadelphia who I really trusted and liked.

 

And, in case you haven't figured it out (which I am sure you have), men like a little meat on your bones in bed.  They might like to look at tall skinny ladies with bones sticking out.  But I don't think it feels great.  Plus, as my spouse always says, if you have an appetite for food, then you most likely have a good libido too ;~)


Comment Page: 1 2   [Next]
Login to replyToggle picture size
 

Latest Comment
Re: FINALLY ... SOMEONE SAYS SOMETHING ABOUT OBAMA-AYERS - yeah you are. you're not even able to verify your...

Read...


 
© 2005-2007 MindSay Interactive LLC
| Terms of Service
| Privacy Policy
My Account
Inbox
Account Settings
Lost Password?
Logout
Blog
Update Blog
Edit Old Entries
Pick a Theme
Customize Design
Modify Plugins
Community
Your Profile
Wiki Pages
MindSay Tags
Video & Photos
Geographic Directory
Inside MindSay
About MindSay
MindSay and RSS
Report Spam
Contact Us
Help