While talking with a friend of mine at work (who is engaged to be married) he said that a long time ago he used to cheat on his girlfriends, having several at one time even. Then he said he had gotten it all out of his system, but he still has to work to be faithful to his fiance. This surprised me a little, because he always talks as if he is so dedicated to her, and I told him so. And then he said something that surprised me. He said "I am dedicated to her, but I have to constantly remind myself of that. Monogamy is not natural. I dont think its easy at all, and I dont think its human nature."

Our conversation changed topic at that point, I think because someone else joined in, but the whole thing really made me think. I agree and disagree with what hes saying. For me, monogamy is very natural, I have a horrible conscience and I am a terrible liar. I could never ever cheat on someone I cared for. And if you arent in a relationship with someone you care for, then what is the point? I think maybe that this nature could be a product of your upbringing, surroundings, beliefs, ect. But who really knows? I will agree that for some people it probably isnt a natural instinct, and not just for men, I know plenty of women who have trouble with monogamy. Society and religion put such an emphasis on it, and obviously it is morally the right thing to do.. yet it is something that can be so hard to achieve. But when you think about that, if monogamy was easy, would it be special? Would you be be grateful to have a faithful partner if everybody did it? Because if it was easy, everyone WOULD do it.. I think that, like marriage, it is a decision you have to keep making, over and over. And there are probably a lot of factors involved in what motivates someone to cheat on their significant other. But it is still a decision they make, fully aware of the consequences and fully aware it is morally wrong (natural or not).

But what do you guys think? Is monogamy natural? Is it natural to you? Once a cheater, always a cheater? Or are there other factors to consider?
 
   

 


Comment Page: 1 2 3   [Next]
 
xavier on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
I think monogamy takes a great deal of submission. There's that presumption that many alpha males need to spread their seed and conquer as much vagina out there as possible-survival of the fittest and yada etc. As humans though, like you said, it is a product of one's beliefs and upbringings that make us different from being just savage creatures with no respect for the sanctity of marriage. Some people just believe being a swinger is more natural...I think it's alright to believe in whatever you want just as long as you know what you're getting yourself into. 

 

A monogamous relationship requires total commitment and absolute truth between both mates, and we all know what happens when someone lies or cheats: that trust is broken...thus relationships get fucked.

whatethelsays on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
I agree. That is what makes us the 'the lucky ones'. Humans have choice. Choose to be monogamous, choose not to be- its just that any choice also means consequences. While most have no problem with the choice part, its the other end of the equation- (((the consequences)))- that people seem to struggle with.
further on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
I agree, it makes perfect sense that monogamy and submission go hand in hand. Because in reality everyone has opportunities to cheat.. but we make a choice. Its choosing to be faithful and honest with your partner.. because maybe you want them to be happy above your own desires?
kitte on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
hmm, in my first marriage.... because i was miserable and tired of trying to make it work, i would say that cheating would have been rather easy if not for my conscience.  Now, in my second marriage i am content and don't think that that would ever happen. the difference being that I want to make this marriage work, it is a joint effort. but the question of once a cheater, always a cheater? I dont think so. if someone finds the one person that makes them truly happy.... i doubt that they would cheat again.
further on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Yeah I think unhappiness can be a huge factor in what drives a person to cheat. But like you said its your conscience, or your beliefs that keep you from doing so, even if you arent happy in your situation. But I understand your point, if someone is totally content with their relationship, they wouldnt feel the need or even the urge to cheat.
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
People like to think we are one step above animals. We are not. Our animalistic nature does not lend itself to monogamy. If one chooses marriage, one should be ready to forgo this nature and be faithful. If not, don't marry. It's that simple.
Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Oh this is such bullsh!t lol -- penguins are monogamous, so of course it is natural.
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
You place your "of course it's natural" on the monogamous shoulders of penguins. Yeah, you've got a real argument there.

Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Can you say that it is UNnatural?

I rest my case.
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
My statement sweeps not if you comprehend instead of just read. It is neither natural nor unnatural. Placing penguins as the center of your viewpoint is absurd.

Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Maybe if you understood the satire in my comment, you would realise that his sweeping statement is pretty absurd too. See, I TRY helping you understand, but it just does not work with you!! =)
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
I understand completely.
myclette on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
But you alluded to  "our animalistic nature" and you also said we are not above being animals.  If someone points out that there are some animals that are monogamous, how is this being absurd?
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
I suppose it's not absurd since it's uh...satire.
myclette on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
You didn't see it as satirical to begin with. 
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Perhaps.
further on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Well yes. I know that SOME animals are monogamous, like penguins. But then some of them arent. And I think maybe its the same for people? It comes more naturally to some than others.
Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Then he has no right making a sweeping statement like "it is unnatural". Whatever, dude!
rancettela on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
He said it to excuse himself, but he seems like a common whore to me.
Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
If I were talking to him, I would say, "Whatever helps you sleep at night!" LOL
rancettela on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
If I were talking to him, I'd give him an incredulous look and walk away. Yes, I am mean tho. Sorry for calling him a whore. lol.
Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Nothing wrong with stating the facts, if you ask me =)
rancettela on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
I don't know why some people justify their behavior and act like no one is going to get hurt. Sometimes I just want to give people a piece of my mind, but sometimes I think it's better if I don't.
Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
I give them a piece of my mind, but you are right for being cautious about taking those steps. I get into some trouble sometimes with that!
rancettela on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Some people are not worth arguing with tho.
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
I make no excuses. I am a whore. No need to apologize.
Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
omg! so you are the boy to whom she refers?!?!

oh boy
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Could be.
Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
oh for pete's sake lol
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Who's pete?
Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
My uncle. Now, for his sake, are you that boy? lol
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
LOL. No, I am not he of whom she speaks.
Andreux on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
I am not lying though, he really is my uncle lol -- I have an Uncle Pete.

You asked!!
goodnightsong on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Actually I do too but it's pretty distant.
onewalrus on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
Humans have a perpetual breeding season not restricted to the impulses of alpha-males or females. Some might say only people who live in fairy-tales of religion pin morality on it and call it "cheating". Others might say that humans are weak and that the fun, excitement, gratification and the thrill are too much for them to overcome and resist. And then there is the issue of appetite. Just as we all have our preferences for different foods, we have them sexually too. Some religions prohibit certain foods as well as sexual restrictions. If you tell someone "Thou shalt not eat pizza" they're gonna really want some pizza. And finally, remember the song "The Thrill is Gone"? Yea, that happens too.
further on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
So you think that people only assume it is natural and right because of the restrictions put on it by religion?
onewalrus on
Re: Monogamy is not natural?
It's easy for people to state they're all for it until they have to deal with the emotions of it. It usually involves deception, lying and overall, disrespect. Players though, have no respect for emotions. Life and people are a game to them. Avoid them if you can. In love and war, there are no rules. However, if you have exchanged vows before your God you're all in for the long haul. The closest I want to come to stating an opinion on this is that the only people who really have a right to surprise and hurt are those who are married. Trust, without vows or a legal contract, is for suckers.

Comment Page: 1 2 3   [Next]
Login to replyToggle picture size
 

Latest Comment
Re: Part of the Plan(isphere) - I miss old Dan....he was taken too soon.

Read...


 
© 2005-2007 MindSay Interactive LLC
| Terms of Service
| Privacy Policy
My Account
Inbox
Account Settings
Lost Password?
Logout
Blog
Update Blog
Edit Old Entries
Pick a Theme
Customize Design
Modify Plugins
Community
Your Profile
Wiki Pages
MindSay Tags
Video & Photos
Geographic Directory
Inside MindSay
About MindSay
MindSay and RSS
Report Spam
Contact Us
Help